Skip to content

Guides for boards

The convenience fee is the first thing your owners will notice

· 3 min read

When a board moves dues collection online, the first email it gets is rarely about the software. It is about the fee. Owners who paid by check for twenty years open the new portal, see a surcharge next to the amount they owe, and conclude the board is skimming. The board did not set the fee and often did not notice it in the contract. It is still the board’s problem.

What the fees actually are

The numbers are public if you look in the help centers rather than the sales pages. One widely used dues platform documents its charges plainly: 3.50% plus 50 cents on card payments, $2.45 on each ACH payment, no American Express, and an option to pass the whole amount to owners as a “convenience and service fee.” That is the honest end of the market. At the other end, a payment processor used by several large management companies has a 1.04-out-of-5 rating on the Better Business Bureau site, where reviewers paying rent through it describe a $155 fee on a $15 payment and roughly $165 on a $2,300 one.

Run the arithmetic for a 40-home association with $150 monthly dues. At $2.45 per ACH payment, owners pay about $1,176 a year in fees to pay the association, or the association absorbs it and raises dues to cover it. Card payments at 3.5% cost the same community roughly $2,500 a year. None of that money reaches the reserve fund.

Why it lands on the board

Owners do not read the platform’s terms; they read the budget notice. If the fee is not in the budget notice and not in the minutes of the meeting where the board chose the platform, the board looks as if it hid something. In practice the board was shown a monthly subscription price and the transaction fees were in a separate document. That is a sales technique, not an accident, and it is worth naming in your own records so the next board understands why the fee exists.

Three questions before you sign

First, what is the fee per ACH payment and per card payment, in dollars and percent, and who pays it by default? Get the answer in writing, not on a call.

Second, can owners still pay without a fee at all, by mailed check or bank bill-pay, and will those payments post to the same ledger? A platform that quietly penalizes the fee-free option is designing for its own revenue.

Third, what does it cost to leave? Ask for the export: the owner ledger, the payment history, and the documents, in a format another system can read. The data ownership page describes what a complete export looks like; if a vendor cannot describe theirs, that is your answer.

Put it in the budget

Whatever platform you choose, the fee belongs in the budget packet as its own line, with a sentence explaining who pays it. Boards that do this get one question at the annual meeting. Boards that do not get the email above, every month, from a different owner.

We publish what Keeper Lane charges on the pricing page and explain how dues post to the books on dues and books, so the comparison is straightforward. For a side-by-side with the platform mentioned above, see Keeper Lane compared with PayHOA; if your dues currently run through a management company’s portal, that comparison covers what changes when the association holds the ledger itself.

Records rules for your state

What your state expects an association to keep, how long, and how fast it must answer an owner, with the citation under every rule: the records law for every state.

More from the blog