When the Foundation for Community Association Research asked boards and managers about their last insurance renewal in its April 2025 survey, 93% of the 509 respondents said the property premium had gone up. Asked how the increase was paid for, 71% named higher regular assessments and 31% a special assessment. For many homeowners associations (HOAs) and condominiums, the master policy is now the line that sets the size of next year’s dues increase.
Why the premium lands on the dues
The master policy insures what the association owns or must insure: the buildings in a condominium, the clubhouse and common areas in a planned community. It is paid from the operating budget, and the operating budget is paid from assessments.
Your owners see the same market on their own policies. The Treasury Department’s Federal Insurance Office reported on January 16, 2025 that average homeowners premiums per policy rose 8.7% faster than inflation from 2018 to 2022.
What one renewal does to one owner
In the April survey, 53% of respondents put the average increase at 11% to 25%, and 36% at 26% to 50%. Take a 40-unit association whose master policy renews at $104,000, up from $80,000. That is a 30% increase and $24,000 a year more. Spread evenly, it is $600 per unit per year, or $50 a month on every owner’s dues, before any other line in the budget moves.
The $50 reaches the next buyer too. Lenders count dues in a buyer’s debt-to-income (DTI) ratio, as our November post on whether HOA fees count against a mortgage explained. At the 6.09% average 30-year rate in Freddie Mac’s survey of February 12, 2026, $50 a month carries about $8,300 of loan. A buyer at the limit qualifies for that much less.
For an owner on a fixed income, $600 a year is a real decision. A board that can show the renewal quote, the carriers the broker approached and the reason for the increase is having a different conversation from one that can show only the new number. Our posts on raising dues without a vote and special assessments cover the notice each one needs.
The deductible is the second increase
In the same survey, 29% said the insurer forced a high deductible or a per-unit deductible at the last renewal. A higher deductible lowers the premium and moves the first part of every loss onto the association. If a covered loss falls inside a $100,000 deductible and the board assesses it evenly, each of 40 owners owes $2,500.
That is where the owner’s own policy comes in. A condominium unit owner’s policy, which insurers call an HO-6, covers the owner’s belongings and the parts of the unit the master policy leaves to the owner. It can also carry loss assessment coverage, which pays the owner’s share of an assessment after a covered loss. Florida sets a floor: a unit owner’s policy must include at least $2,000 of it (Fla. Stat. 627.714). Owners should ask their agent whether that coverage reaches an assessment for the association’s deductible, and how far.
Owners can check only what they know. Tell them the deductible, in writing, every time it changes.
What to put on the record
Some states write the disclosure into law. In California, the annual budget report summarizes the association’s property, general liability, earthquake, flood and fidelity policies, with each insurer, limit and deductible (Civil Code 5300). If a policy lapses or there is “a significant change, such as a reduction in coverage or limits or an increase in the deductible,” every member gets individual notice (Civil Code 5810). In a Florida condominium, the board sets deductibles at a meeting held the way the budget meeting is, the replacement cost is determined at least once every three years, and current insurance policies are official records (Fla. Stat. 718.111). Our December post on the Florida reserve study deadline covers the inspection records that belong beside them.
Wherever you are, keep four things together: the policy and its declarations page, the renewal quotes, the insurable value appraisal, and the minutes of the meeting that accepted the renewal and set the deductible. The California and Florida pages list each state’s records, owner inspection rights explain what owners may ask to see, and the retention checklist shows how long your state expects the policies and minutes kept.
In Keeper Lane, those documents are filed against your state’s checklist, a board member publishes the insurance summary to owners when it is confirmed, and the premium sits on its own line in a budget adopted at its meeting and tracked through the year.
The renewal sets the dues. Put the reasons in writing before the notice goes out.
Sources: Foundation for Community Association Research, Insurance Coverage Trends Snap Survey, April 2025 · U.S. Treasury, Federal Insurance Office homeowners insurance report, January 16, 2025 · Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, 2026 · Florida Statutes 627.714 (2025) · Florida Statutes 718.111 (2025) · California Civil Code 5300 · California Civil Code 5810